Jacob enjoys his quiet life running a coffee shop, renting out his cottage, and going for hikes with his dog. This all changes when someone who looks like his dead ex-girlfriend shows up to rent his cottage. Strange things start happening, leading him to believe that he isn't the only one who knows how his ex-girlfriend died.
Everyone in Fairview knows how beloved high school senior Andie Bell was killed by Sal Singh, who then killed himself. Pippa doesn't think the evidence adds up, so she decides to investigate the five year old case for her senior project. However, things take a turn when it's obvious someone doesn't want her digging into the facts.